Code and Other Laws of Cyberspace
by Lawrence Lessig
A review
by Holly Gunn
 
GlossaryBACKHOMENext

Amicus curiae
Latin for "friend of the court".  An individual or an organization interested in an issue files a brief or participates in the argument in a case in which that party or organization is not one of the litigants. Lawrence Lessig files briefs on in various cases that threaten values he believes should be preserved on the Internet or in the media.  Usually the court must give permission for the brief to be filed, and arguments may only be made with the agreement of the party.  The amicus curiae is supporting, and that argument comes out of the time allowed for that party's presentation to the court.

Appellee
The name used for the party who has won at the trial court level, but the loser (appellant) has appealed the decision to a higher court. Thus the appellee has to file a response to the legal brief filed by the appellant. In many jurisdictions the appellee is called the "respondent."

Avatar space
Virtual space.  In Hinduism, the descent of a deity, or released soul, to earth in bodily form. Avatar space grew out of the "MUD" or "M00" text-based "virtual" worlds. In a MUD or MOO space you create objects and identities and have them do things, but the objects action are text-based. 

Brandeis, Louis Dembitz Brandeis (1856-1941)
Associate Justice of the Supreme Court of the United States from 1916-1939. He was a child of German Jewish immigrants, a brilliant attorney, a leader of the Progressive movement, and an active Zionist. President Woodrow Wilson nominated  Louis Brandeis to the Supreme Court.  William Howard Taft, a conservative who served as President of the United States (1909-1913) and Chief Justice of the Supreme Court (1921-1930) opposed his nomination. Brandeis's appointment broke down a taboo on Jews serving in the Supreme Court and high positions in government and education.  Brandeis became famous for reforming legal arguments.

Case Law
Decisions of the appeals courts and other courts which make new interpretations of the law and, therefore, can be cited as precedents. These interpretations are distinguished from "statutory law," which is the statutes and codes (laws) enacted by legislative bodies; "regulatory law," which is regulations required by agencies based on statutes; and in some areas, the common law, which is the generally accepted law carried down from England. The rulings in trials and hearings which are not appealed and not reported are not case law and, therefore, not precedent or new interpretations. Law students principally study case law to understand the application of law to facts and learn the courts' subsequent interpretations of statutes.

Civil Liberties
In the United States, civil liberties are those rights or freedoms given to the people by the First Amendment to the Constitution, by Common Law, or legislation, allowing the individual to be free to speak, think, assemble,
organize, worship, or petition without government (or even private) interference or restraints.

Code
A set of instructions that control how the software and hardware that make cyberspace work. Code is made and it is made by us.  Lessig believes that the users of the Internet should have input into what this code will be like.

Constitution
The fundamental, underlying document which establishes the government of a nation or state. The U.S. Constitution  is one example. 

Constitution as discussed by Lessig
When Lessig speak of constitution, he does not mean legal text. He speaks of constitution in the British sense, not just a legal text.  He refers to "an architecture that structures and constrains social and legal power, to the end of protecting fundamental values -- the principles and ideals that reach beyond the compromises of ordinary politics."  (Lessig. Code. 1999. p.5)

Constitutional rights
Rights given or reserved for people by the constitution.

East Coast Code
This is the code that that Congress enacts, an array of statutes that state how citizens are to behave. Some of this code controls citizens, some controls companies, some bureaucrats.  Lessig calls these government regulations that come out of Washington East Coast Code.

Declan McCullagh
McCullagh is is the Washington bureau chief for Wired News, and an advocate for libertarianism on the Net.  He is totally against government intervention with the Internet.  It is on this point that he and Lessig disagree.  A chapter of Lessig's book, Code and other laws of cyberspace,  is called "What Declan doesn't get."  Declan and Lessig have faced off on the Internet many times. A Web space,  http://www.what-declan-doesnt-get.com, was started,  and finally, McCullagh finally issued an Declan type of apology to Lessig on the Net, complete with a poetic tribute,  admitting he was outclassed. " I deeply regret the errors of my ways, hereby issue a full retraction" . (McCullagh. http://lists.insecure.org/politech/1999/Nov/0042.html 1999. )

Microsoft Antitrust Court Case Civil Action No. 98-1233 (TPJ) 
STATE OF NEW YORK, ex rel.  Attorney General ELIOT SPITZER, et al., Plaintiffs and Counterclaim-Defendants, v.  MICROSOFT CORPORATION, Defendant and Counterclaim-Plaintiff. 
Judge Penfield Jackson determined that Microsoft held a monopoly in computer operating systems, and issued a  decisive statement , called a "finding a fact", not a verdict that stated: 
"Microsoft enjoys so much power in the market for Intel-compatible PC operating systems that if it wished to exercise this power solely in terms of price, it could charge a price for Windows substantially above that which could be charged in a competitive market. Moreover, it could do so for a significant period of time without losing an unacceptable amount of business to competitors," he added. "In other words, Microsoft enjoys monopoly power in the relevant market."  (Jackson, 1999 quoted IN Wilcox. 1999.)
Open code software
Code that the user community could openly modify and improve.  Open code software is developed in the public interest, and is  flexible, strong, smooth-running, low-priced or free. Open source software is developed by uncoordinated, but collaborating programmers, using freely distributed source code and the communications facilities of the Internet

Proprietary software
Proprietary software is software, whose use, redistribution or modification is prohibited, or requires a user to ask for permission, or is restricted so much that a user effectively cannot do it freely. Proprietary software is generally commercial. 

Sovereignty
Absolute and independent authority of a community or a nation

Tort Law
The word tort comes from the French word for "wrong," a civil wrong or wrongful act, whether intentional or accidental,  from which injury occurs to another. Torts include all negligence cases as well as
intentional wrongs which result in harm.  Tort law is one of the major areas of law.

Y2K
Many computer programs resident in computer chips or in software routines have dates stored in a two  digit format.  This does not account for a transition from 99 to 00.  An unexpected result can occur, like the calculation of a negative number or a failure on the part of the software to proceed.  As it turned out,  the Y2K crisis was overblown.  Nonetheless,  businesses and corporations spent a lot of money upgrading equipment and making contingency plans to survive the problems that the dawning of the new millennium would bring to computer systems. 

West Coast Code
Code that code writers construct.  Those instructions embedded in the hardware and software that makes cyberspace work is called West Coast code.  This is the code written by code writers, originally in Silicon Valley, hence the name West Coast.  When commerce writes code, code can be controlled, because commercial entities can be controlled by East Coast code as government regulates the commercial enterprises.  Thus, East Coast code can exert power over West Coast Code.

 


Legal definitions were taken form or verified in  Hill, Gerald, and Hill, Kathleen.  Law.com dictionary. Santa Monica, California, General Publishing Group. Online. Available: http://dictionary.law.com/  18 August  2001.
Lawrence Lessig | Lessig On... | The Review | Implications for Schools | Bibliography | Credits